Each member of Harry's 1980 senior high school class receives the same threatening letter before their 20th year reunion. Most take it as a joke, but Mrs. Murphy senses trouble. And she's right when the class womanizer is found with a bullet between his eyes. While Harry tries to piece together the puzzle, Mrs. Murphy and her animal pals try to sniff out the truth.
"You'll never get old."

Each member of the class of 1980 has received the letter. Mary Minor "Harry" Haristeen, who is on the organizing committee for Crozet High's twentieth reunion, decides to take it as a compliment. Others think it's a joke.

But Mrs. Murphy senses trouble. And the sly tiger cat is soon proven right ... when the class womanizer turns up dead with a bullet between his eyes. Then another note followed by another murder makes it clear that someone has waited twenty years to take revenge.

While Harry tries to piece together the puzzle, it's up to Mrs. Murphy and her animal pals to sniff out the truth. And there isn't much time. Mrs. Murphy is the first to realize that Harry has been chosen Most Likely to Die, and if she doesn't hurry, Crozet High's twentieth reunion could be Harry's last.