While trying to help Clint figure out how something like this could happen, Amy Cooke stumbles upon an old newspaper article that details an unsolved case from nineteen years earlier. The details are sketchy, but it seems that a woman went missing after an argument with her husband. The husband's story is fishy and the woman's family suspects foul play, but there are no reports or evidence from back then to assist with the investigation, so Amy's left trying to recreate the file from scratch.

There's a chance that neither case will be solved, but one thing can be counted on: Clint and Amy will die trying.